| Stat |
Game |
Season |
Career |
| Kicking points |
17 - Jerry Porter vs. Anderson - 2017 (3 FGM, 8 PATs) |
80 - Kyle Farfsing - 2023 |
241 - Kyle Farfsing - 2019-23 |
| Most Field Goals Attempted |
4 - Dominic Iannarino vs. Wilmington 1993 |
14 - Mike Riga - 2003 |
34 - Kevin Koch (2004-07) |
| Most field goals made |
4 - Dominic Iannarino vs. Wilmington 1993 |
11 - Shane Kelly - 2013 |
21 - Shane Kelly (2013-14) |
| Longest:Â |
 48, Shane Kelly vs. Hanover 2014, Jerry Porter vs Anderson 2017 |
|
|
| Most extra points attempted |
10 - Kyle Farfsing vs. Rose-Hulman 2023 |
78 - Kyle Farfsing - 2023 |
199 - Kyle Farfsing (2019-23) |
| Most extra points made |
8 - Kevin Kock vs. Bluffton 2004, Jerry Porter vs. Anderson 2017 & vs. Earlham 2018, Kyle Farfsing vs. Rose-Hulman 2023 |
71 - Kyle Farfsing - 2023 |
181 - Kyle Farfsing (2019-23) |
| Most punts |
11 - Dan Benjamin vs. Georgetown 1992, Jon Atwood vs. Defiance 2003, Joe Vortkamp vs. Defiance 2008 |
67 -- Greg Tabar - 2011 |
211 - Greg Tabar (2010-13) |
| Punt yardage |
463 - Jon Atwood vs. Defiance 2003 |
2,289 - Neil Skirvin - 2007 |
8,076 - Greg Tabar (2010-13) |
| Longest:Â |
88, Neil Skirvin vs. Defiance 2006 |
|
|
| Punt average |
54.0 - Shane Kelly vs. Anderson (3 for 162) (minimum 2 punts) |
39.1 - Greg Tabar - 2012 (52 for 2,031) (minimum 20 punts) |
38.3 - Greg Tabar (2010-13)(211 for 8,076) (50 punts minimum) |
| Punt returns |
10 - Andy Wellendorf vs. Defiance 2003 |
29 - Andy Wellendorf - 2003 |
87 - Andy Wellendorf (2002-05) |
| Punt return yardage |
226 - Tro Speakman vs. Earlham 2017 |
415 - Troy Speakman 2017 |
1,118 - Troy Speakman (2017-21) |
| Punt return average |
32.3 - Troy Speakman vs. Earlham 2017 (7 for 226) *minimum 4 returns |
19.6 - Jason Jackson 1990 (10 for 196) *minimum 10 returns |
14.8 - Jason Jackson (1990-94) (26 for 384) *minimum 20 returns |
| Punt return TDs |
2 - Troy Speakman vs. Earlham 2017 |
|
4 - Troy Speakman (2017-21) |
| Longest Punt Return TD |
95 - Marvin Draper vs. Finlandia 2015 |
|
|
| Kickoff returns |
7 - Troy Speakman vs. Franklin 2017 & Devon Donawerth vs Rose-Hulman 2021 |
24 - Troy Speakman - 2018 |
84 - Troy Speakman (2017-21) |
| Kickoff return yardage |
135 - Devon Donawerth vs. Rose-Hulman 2021 |
548 - Nate Rawe - 2009 |
1,652 - Troy Speakman (2017-21) |
| Kickoff return average |
51.5 - Casey Alberts vs. Sue Bennett 1996 (2 for 103) *minimum of 2 returns |
35.6 - David Sanders - 2005 (10 for 356) *minimum 10 returns |
22.6 - Jason Jackson (1990-94) (53 for 1,198) *minimum 50 returns |
| Kickoff return TDs |
|
|
2 - Casey Alberts (1994-97) |
| Longest for TD |
 93 Casey Albertz vs. Hanover 1995 |
|
|
